Benami London home for Robert Vadra linked to arms dealer, suggests report accessed by NDTV
NDTV accesses two government reports on Robert Vadra
Arms dealer bought benami London house for Vadra: Report
"Completely incorrect and false assumption": Vadra's lawyer
The government has begun a new investigation into Robert Vadra, the son-in-law of Congress chief Sonia Gandhi, to determine if a controversial arms dealer bought a "benami" or proxy-owned mansion in London for him in 2009.
Robert Vadra's lawyers have denied the charges completely. "Robert Vadra has been systematically prosecuted and hounded by Congress opponents," said Congress spokesperson Randeep Surjewala.
The government investigation is based on two reports by investigating agencies. The reports quote from emails allegedly sent by Robert Vadra and his executive assistant, Manoj Arora. NDTV has accessed the reports but cannot confirm the authenticity of the emails. The reports also include details from the questioning of controversial arms dealer Sanjay Bhandari.
Last month, enforcement agencies raided 18 premises owned by Sanjay Bhandari. Two preliminary reports prepared after the raids state that Robert Vadra and his executive assistant sent several emails discussing payments and renovations for a London home (12 Ellerton House, Bryanston Square) bought for 19 lakh GBP (R
19 crores) in October 2009 and sold in June 2010.
The emails were sent to Sumit Chadda, a relative of Sanjay Bhandari's based in London.
One report says, "There was an email dated 4.04.2010 in which Sumit Chadda reported the progress of work of renovation and repair work to Robert Vadra and asked for reimbursement of expenses."
The report then quotes Robert Vadra replying to Sumit Chadda saying "He would look into the issue" and added that his "secretary" Manoj will be "in touch". Thereafter, the report says, "Subsequently Mr Manoj kept in touch with Sumit Chadda using an email ID 'Exim Real Estate'".
Government officers who spoke to NDTV on the condition of anonymity say the emails exchanged also refer to redecorating the property, including its chandeliers.
One of the reports says "Sanjay Bhandari was specifically questioned whether Robert Vadra was the beneficiary of the sale of the Bryanston Square property in London. He did not deny the same but avoided a direct answer by stating that he would he able to confirm it by referring it to sale deed kept with his lawyer in London."
Robert Vadra is being investigated for controversial land deals in Haryana when the Congress was in power (File photo)
Robert Vadra's lawyers have said he "does not own directly or indirectly, any house described by you as No 12, Ellerton House, Bryanston Square, London" and that Robert Vadra and his assistant "have not entered into any transaction of a financial nature with Mr Sanjay Bhandari and are not even aware that Mr Sanjay Bhandari is involved in any defense transaction."
"It is shocking but not surprising," said BJP parliamentarian Kirit Somaiya to NDTV. "I would approach the Enforcement Directorate, Income Tax, and request them to check the property and any non-transparency in the transaction."
Sanjay Bhandari is the owner of Offset India Solutions (OIS). A covert Intelligence Bureau report had red-flagged his business dealings in 2014 right after the Modi government took office and advised the Defence Ministry to keep him at a distance.
Sanjay Bhandari, government officers say, tried to destroy his BlackBerry phone during the raids. However, they were able to recover data from his handset and his computers. Sanjay Bhandari's public relations office asked NDTV for a detailed questionnaire which was sent to them, but they have yet to respond.
Sanjay Bhandari formed OIS in 2008 with a paid-up capital of only one lakh rupees. Its rapid escalation into a multi-crore venture caught the attention of financial crime investigators. He is now being investigated for financial violations linked to 35 suspected shell companies between 2009 and 2014. Recently, OIS won a deal to supply parts for 38 combat aircraft that India is buying from Dassault Aviation.
Robert Vadra is being investigated for land deals in Haryana while the Congress governed the state to determine if he got special discounts and other benefits that allowed him windfall gain. He has denied any wrongdoing.
Complete statement from Robert Vadra's lawyers
[if IE]> https://html2-f.
scribd. scribd. scribd. scribd.
1. Ms. Barkha Dutt
2. Ms. Tanima Biswas
Dear Ms. Barkha Dutt Ms. Tanima Biswas,
Our Clients: Mr. Robert !"r! # Mr. M!no$ Aror!
Re.: Your en%uir& 'i"e &our e-(!ils "!te" )*
M!&, )/ !n" 0
M!&, )/ !""resse" to our Clients b& Ms. T!ni(! Bis1!s
!ur "lients ha#e han$e$ %#er t% me a &%'y %( y%ur a(%rementi%ne$ e-mails sent t% them
with instru&ti%ns t% state as un$er:
!ur "lients wish t% state that Mr. )%*ert Va$ra $%es n%t %wn, $ire&tly %r
in$ire&tly, any h%use $es&ri*e$ *y y%u as h%use N%. 12, Ellert%n +%use, Bryanst%n
uare, %n$%n. !ur "lients re/ret that y%u are 'r%&ee$in/ %n a &%m'letely
in&%rre&t an$ (alse assum'ti%n.
!ur "lients ha#e n% *usiness relati%ns with Mr. anay Bhan$ari. !ur "lients
(urther state that %ur "lients ha#e n%t entere$ int% any transa&ti%n %( a (inan&ial
nature with Mr. anay Bhan$ari an$ are n%t e#en aware that Mr. anay Bhan$ari
is in#%l#e$ in any $e(ense transa&ti%n. !ur "lients ha#e s&ru'ul%usly a#%i$e$
e#en *ein/ rem%tely in#%l#e$ in relati%n t% any $e(ense transa&ti%n.
!ur "lients are $ee'ly an/uishe$ that a res'%nsi*le TV &hannel sh%ul$ un$ertake
a #enture int% s'rea$in/ in&%rre&t in(%rmati%n that &%ul$ un$%u*te$ly &ause
$isuiet. !ur "lients h%'e that *etter sense will 're#ail.
!ur "lients ha#e n%t *een sh%wn any s% &alle$ emails an$ %*#i%usly &ann%t
&%mment %n them. n any e#ent %ur "lients '%siti%n is &lear as state$ a*%#e.
n the e#ent this &lari(i&ati%n %( %ur "lients is n%t su((i&iently a$$resse$, %ur
"lients w%ul$ *e &%m'elle$ t% take re&%urse t% le/al reme$ies as they may *e
a$#ise$. !ur "lients a$$ that sin&e they res'e&t the 'ress this w%ul$ *e the last
&%urse t% *e a$%'te$.
!ur "lients w%ul$ *e at li*erty t% 'r%&ee$ a/ainst any 'ers%n wh% is $ire&tly %r
in$ire&tly ass%&iate$ %r res'%nsi*le (%r &ausin/ the sai$ tele&ast %r 'u*li&ati%n %(
!ur "lients are law a*i$in/ &itien %( n$ia an$ ha#e at all times &arrie$ %n their
*usiness in a&&%r$an&e with law.
This letter is *ein/ sent with%ut 'reu$i&e t% any ri/hts an$ &%ntenti%ns %( %ur
"lients an$ n%thin/ &%ntaine$ herein sh%ul$ *e &%nsi$ere$ an a$missi%n %( any
(a&t %r a wai#er %( any %( the ri/hts an$ reme$ies %( %ur "lients.
9%r M;N <+;T;N = "!.
>M;N ?8!T <+;T;N@
Suman Khaitan & Co.
Khaitan & Partners
W-1! West Win"! #reater Kailash Part-$$
Ph: +,1 11 )( ,)) / )1 ,, / )1) 0*0
2a3: +,1 11 ,1 01(*
S-)(! #reater Kailash Part-$$
Ph: +,1 11 ),( 1((
2a3: +,1 11 ),( 1,,
4his messa"e 5includin" an6 attachment5s7 hereto7 is con8idential and ma6 also 9e privile"ed. $t is intended solel6 8or
the addressee. 4his communication is 8or the e3clusive use o8 the addressee and the intended recipient5s7 and shall
not 9e 8orarded to an6 third part6 ithout 8irst o9tainin" ritten authorisation 8rom Suman Khaitan & Co./Khaitan &
Partners. $8 6ou are not the intended recipient 6ou are here96 noti8ied that an6 disclosure! cop6in"! distri9ution or
takin" an6 action in reliance on the contents o8 this in8ormation is strictl6 prohi9ited and ma6 9e unla8ul. $t ma6
contain in8ormation hich is con8idential and le"all6 privile"ed and the same shall not 9e used or dealt ith 96 an6
third part6 in an6 manner hatsoever ithout the speci8ic consent o8 Suman Khaitan & Co./Khaitan & Partners. $8 6ou
have received this messa"e in error 6ou are reuested to delete it alon"ith all attachments and copies! i8 an6! 8rom
6our s6stem and to contact the sender 96 repl6in" to this messa"e immediatel6. Suman Khaitan & Co./Khaitan &
Partners is not lia9le 8or the improper transmission o8 this messa"e nor 8or an6 dama"e sustained as a result o8 this
messa"e. We do not "uarantee that this material is 8ree 8rom viruses or an6 other de8ects.
Source: NDTV a few minutes ago.